Canada inquiry into China election meddling claims ruled out

An independent special rapporteur has said that Canada should hold public hearings into foreign interference by China, but stopped short from recommending a formal public inquiry.

The advice is in response to claims that China attempted to interfere in Canada’s last two federal elections.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has been pressured to launch a formal probe.

Chinese officials have previously denied any interference, calling the accusations “defamatory”.

The prime minister appointed David Johnston, Canada’s former governor general, in March as special rapporteur to investigate the interference allegations.

At a news conference on Tuesday, Mr Johnston said that foreign governments are “undoubtedly attempting to influence candidates in Canada”.

However, he said a public inquiry into this influence would not be possible due to the sensitivity of the intelligence involved.

Mr Johnston said he made his conclusions after reviewing classified reports and interviewing senior politicians and intelligence officials.

“What has allowed me to determine whether there has in fact been interference cannot be disclosed publicly,” Mr Johnston said. “A public review of classified intelligence simply cannot be done.”

Instead, in an early report into interference claims, he recommended that a series of public hearings be held to discuss what he described as “serious shortcomings in the way intelligence is communicated from security agencies to the various government departments” in Canada around detecting and deterring foreign interference.

“These serious gaps must be addressed and corrected,” his report concluded. 

The allegations of foreign interference stem from a steady drip of reports, mostly based on leaked intelligence, in Canadian media in recent months that detailed claims of Chinese meddling in the country’s last two federal elections, in 2019 and 2021.

The efforts are not believed to have altered the outcome of either general elections, but have rocked Canadian politics.

Mr Trudeau has faced significant pressure from political rivals to launch a public inquiry into the claims.

Mr Johnston’s report was critical of some of the media reports on the meddling claims, saying they were based on limited information and lacked context. 

And while Mr Trudeau’s government has faced accusations it failed to act on specific instances of interference, Mr Johnston said he found no example of the prime minister or others “knowingly ignoring intelligence, advice or recommendations on foreign interference”.

Mr Johnston’s report was criticised by Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre, who accused the special rapporteur of being friendly to Mr Trudeau and not impartial on the file.

“We need a full public inquiry to get to the bottom of Beijing’s influence into our democracy,” Mr Poilievre said at a news conference.

Mr Johnson called attacks on his integrity “baseless accusations”.

Allegations of Chinese meddling in Canadian politics have dominated headlines in recent months.

Intelligence reports have also detailed accusations that Beijing targeted a member of parliament and his family in Hong Kong after the politician accused China of human rights abuses.In response, Canada declared diplomat Zhao Wei “persona non grata” earlier this month and ordered him to leave the country.

The next day China ordered the removal of Canada’s diplomat in Shanghai, Jennifer Lynn Lalonde.China has repeatedly denied any interference in Canadian politics, and has accused Canada of “slander and defamation” following its expulsion of its diplomat.The issue has strained already challenging diplomatic relations between the two countries.