Judge strikes significant blow against groups who want Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene disqualified from office
Politics of the Day
Attorney Andrew G. Celli Jr. discusses his cross-examination of Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) during a hearing in Atlanta to determine if Greene is constitutionally barred from running for reelection because of her alleged role in the January 6 insurrection.
” data-duration=”02:41″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”Attorney who questioned Marjorie Taylor Greene reacts to her testimony” data-index=”idx-0″ data-show-name=”New Day” data-show-url=”https://www.cnn.com/shows/new-day” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_59f759bac0a2aedfdd405394b5da168e-h_ad05124ff9cdcc81a64bdc6a383518c2-pageTop@published” data-video-id=”politics/2022/04/25/marjorie-taylor-greene-attorney-candidacy-insurrection-newday-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_59f759bac0a2aedfdd405394b5da168e-h_ad05124ff9cdcc81a64bdc6a383518c2-pageTop@published”>
Now playing
Attorney who questioned Marjorie Taylor Greene reacts to her testimony
Newly released audio reveals Republican House Leader Kevin McCarthy denounced former President Trump’s involvement in the insurrection, calling his behavior “atrocious and totally wrong.”
” data-duration=”04:11″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”‘Atrocious and totally wrong’: Audio reveals McCarthy denounced Trump’s behavior” data-index=”idx-1″ data-show-name=”The Lead” data-show-url=”https://www.cnn.com/shows/the-lead” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_c3459a742d86b328d30350083ab6f2c2″ data-video-id=”politics/2022/05/04/kevin-mccarthy-audio-denounced-donald-trump-after-insurrection-sot-lead-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_c3459a742d86b328d30350083ab6f2c2″>
Now playing
‘Atrocious and totally wrong’: Audio reveals McCarthy denounced Trump’s behavior
During a Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs hearing, Department of Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas pushed back after Republican Sen. Rick Scott asked about the Biden administration’s approach to US-Cuba relations.
” data-duration=”02:46″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”‘Respect my humanity’: Mayorkas pushes back after GOP senator’s question” data-index=”idx-2″ data-show-name=”” data-show-url=”” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_8c413c12733cda0a51b4a4b50fa0af4a” data-video-id=”politics/2022/05/04/alejandro-mayorkas-rick-scott-cuba-sot-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_8c413c12733cda0a51b4a4b50fa0af4a”>
Now playing
‘Respect my humanity’: Mayorkas pushes back after GOP senator’s question
CNN political director David Chalian breaks down a new poll that shows Americans ranking the economy as their top concern, while also giving President Biden poor marks on his handling of the issue.
” data-duration=”02:20″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”‘Bottom of the heap’: New CNN poll shows Biden’s numbers falling further” data-index=”idx-3″ data-show-name=”The Lead” data-show-url=”https://www.cnn.com/shows/the-lead” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_52fd59dd1f1bc8db65a4f9b49bf72503″ data-video-id=”politics/2022/05/04/biden-new-poll-economy-biggest-issue-lead-chalian-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_52fd59dd1f1bc8db65a4f9b49bf72503″>
Now playing
‘Bottom of the heap’: New CNN poll shows Biden’s numbers falling further
CNN’s John King and Abby Phillip break down the CNN projection that J.D. Vance will win the Ohio Senate Republican primary.
” data-duration=”03:40″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”CNN projects J.D. Vance wins Ohio GOP Senate primary” data-index=”idx-4″ data-show-name=”” data-show-url=”” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_cc641e05d7e1deb6f1cf9d23de5ac5e1″ data-video-id=”politics/2022/05/04/ohio-senate-gop-jd-vance-2022-midterm-primaries-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_cc641e05d7e1deb6f1cf9d23de5ac5e1″>
Now playing
CNN projects J.D. Vance wins Ohio GOP Senate primary
Since the landmark 1973 Supreme Court decision in Roe v Wade, which established the legal right to abortion in the United States, nominees to the highest court have been asked about their views on abortion during their confirmation hearings. They’ve also been asked about Casey v Planned Parenthood, a 1991 decision that established the “undue burden test” by which abortion regulations are judged.
” data-duration=”02:50″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”This is what the Supreme Court justices said about abortion as nominees” data-index=”idx-5″ data-show-name=”” data-show-url=”” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_4b1c172df02ee0aa7f3fc10879d4367f” data-video-id=”politics/2021/09/02/supreme-court-justices-abortion-orig-vf.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_4b1c172df02ee0aa7f3fc10879d4367f”>
Now playing
This is what the Supreme Court justices said about abortion as nominees
Ohio Senate Democratic nominee Tim Ryan joins CNN’s New Day to discuss Republican nominee J.D Vance’s claims that Ryan is trying to portray himself as a “Trump Democrat.” Ryan explains that is it not about the party, but about being an American and focusing on the issues important to the people.
” data-duration=”02:54″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”See how Tim Ryan reacts to being called a ‘Trump Democrat'” data-index=”idx-6″ data-show-name=”New Day” data-show-url=”https://www.cnn.com/shows/new-day” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_6886d0a8c28c00214350694c3ebd95b3″ data-video-id=”politics/2022/05/04/tim-ryan-ohio-trump-democrat-newday-berman-intv-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_6886d0a8c28c00214350694c3ebd95b3″>
Now playing
See how Tim Ryan reacts to being called a ‘Trump Democrat’
Former GOP lawmaker Mia Love and CNN legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin debate the real-world implications of a draft majority opinion, obtained by Politico, that would overturn Roe v. Wade.
” data-duration=”04:42″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”Toobin pushes back on former GOP lawmaker about Roe v. Wade” data-index=”idx-7″ data-show-name=”Anderson Cooper 360″ data-show-url=”https://www.cnn.com/shows/ac-360″ data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_da30b1fbb9154ac553a9c47118648657″ data-video-id=”politics/2022/05/04/mia-love-jeffrey-toobin-scotus-draft-opinion-abortion-ac360-sot-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_da30b1fbb9154ac553a9c47118648657″>
Now playing
Toobin pushes back on former GOP lawmaker about Roe v. Wade
Senator Susan Collins (R-ME) said in 2018 that she was convinced Supreme Court Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh wouldn’t overturn Roe v. Wade. Now if the Supreme Court overturns it, it would be “completely inconsistent” with what the two purported, Collins said following news of the draft opinion.
” data-duration=”01:06″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”Watch: Sen. Susan Collins saying Supreme Court Justices won’t overturn Roe v. Wade” data-index=”idx-8″ data-show-name=”The Lead” data-show-url=”https://www.cnn.com/shows/the-lead” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_71065a90f82a95a465a0cdc57a58acc6″ data-video-id=”politics/2022/05/03/susan-collins-montage-roe-v-wade-gorsuch-kavanaugh-the-lead-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_71065a90f82a95a465a0cdc57a58acc6″>
Now playing
Watch: Sen. Susan Collins saying Supreme Court Justices won’t overturn Roe v. Wade
President Biden spoke out for the first time since a draft of the Supreme Court opinion that would strike down Roe v. Wade was leaked.
” data-duration=”04:55″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”Biden speaks out on draft SCOTUS opinion to overturn Roe v. Wade” data-index=”idx-9″ data-show-name=”AT THIS HOUR” data-show-url=”https://www.cnn.com/shows/at-this-hour” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_b9ff3d975df15d21392f877901a617e3″ data-video-id=”politics/2022/05/03/biden-speaks-out-scotus-roe-v-wade-abortion-ath-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_b9ff3d975df15d21392f877901a617e3″>
Now playing
Biden speaks out on draft SCOTUS opinion to overturn Roe v. Wade
Josh Gerstein, the Politico reporter who co-wrote the story on what they call a draft of a majority opinion written by Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito that would strike down Roe v. Wade, explains to CNN’s John Berman why the language in the draft is important.
” data-duration=”02:09″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”‘Almost contemptuous’: Reporter who broke SCOTUS story on draft opinion language” data-index=”idx-10″ data-show-name=”New Day” data-show-url=”https://www.cnn.com/shows/new-day” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_67e72984edac14f82e7d984d48dff3ac” data-video-id=”politics/2022/05/03/politico-reporter-supreme-court-roe-v-wade-opinion-reaction-newday-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_67e72984edac14f82e7d984d48dff3ac”>
Now playing
‘Almost contemptuous’: Reporter who broke SCOTUS story on draft opinion language
Dr. LeRoy Carhart operates one of just three abortion clinics in Nebraska. Listen to his fears about what would happen if Roe v. Wade is overturned.
” data-duration=”02:06″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”Long-time abortion provider: ‘Women will start dying'” data-index=”idx-11″ data-show-name=”” data-show-url=”” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_5d3484d63cdac4bda0ccdf1fef87a8d1″ data-video-id=”health/2022/05/04/nebraska-maryland-abortion-provider-interview-roe-v-wade-orig-jk-mss.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_5d3484d63cdac4bda0ccdf1fef87a8d1″>
Now playing
Long-time abortion provider: ‘Women will start dying’
Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) and CNN’s Don Lemon look back on how Trump’s Supreme Court nominees answered questions about Roe vs. Wade during their confirmation hearings.
” data-duration=”02:38″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”‘Woah’: Klobuchar reacts to what Trump’s SCOTUS nominees said about abortion during confirmations” data-index=”idx-12″ data-show-name=”Don Lemon Tonight” data-show-url=”https://www.cnn.com/shows/cnn-tonight” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_351f4620872d5c72c6f7f810c2990b04″ data-video-id=”politics/2022/05/03/roe-v-wade-republican-trump-supreme-court-nominees-shift-decisions-klobuchar-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_351f4620872d5c72c6f7f810c2990b04″>
Now playing
‘Woah’: Klobuchar reacts to what Trump’s SCOTUS nominees said about abortion during confirmations
In Ohio and Pennsylvania Republican Senate debates one name is on the lips of every candidate: Donald Trump. CNN’s Gabby Orr explains why.
” data-duration=”03:19″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”These Senate candidates like to mention Trump. A lot” data-index=”idx-13″ data-show-name=”” data-show-url=”” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_0c057c504fed43d02b65e3b73a84f1d2″ data-video-id=”politics/2022/04/29/gop-candidates-ohio-and-pennsylvania-trump-orig-jm-vf.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_0c057c504fed43d02b65e3b73a84f1d2″>
Now playing
These Senate candidates like to mention Trump. A lot
Republican governor Asa Hutchinson of Arkansas tells CNN’s Dana Bash he is considering a run for presidential office in 2024.
” data-duration=”01:31″ data-editable=”settings” data-headline=”GOP governor says presidental run for 2024 is ‘on the table'” data-index=”idx-14″ data-show-name=”State of the Union” data-show-url=”https://www.cnn.com/shows/state-of-the-union” data-source=”CNN” data-uri=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_143390237dec4e42e3c14a18b867f6d5″ data-video-id=”politics/2022/05/01/governor-asa-hutchinson-arkansas-considers-presidential-run-2024-sot-sotu-vpx.cnn” data-video-instance=”archive.cms.cnn.com/_components/video-resource/instances/h_143390237dec4e42e3c14a18b867f6d5″>
Now playing
GOP governor says presidental run for 2024 is ‘on the table’
CNN —
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, the conspiracy theory-peddling Georgia Republican, shouldn’t be disqualified over her role in the January 6 insurrection, a judge said Friday in a significant legal blow to the voters and advocacy groups who tried to throw her off the ballot.
State Judge Charles Beaudrot said in a 19-page recommendation that even if it is assumed that the US Capitol riot was an insurrection, “challengers have produced insufficient evidence to show that Rep. Greene ‘engaged’ in that insurrection after she took the oath of office on January 3, 2021.”
The recommendation will now be taken up by Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger, a Republican. It’s possible, but highly unlikely, that Raffensperger would overrule the judge’s recommendation and disqualify Greene on his own. The anti-Greene challengers can still appeal Raffensperger’s decision in state courts.
The Republican primary in Georgia is scheduled for May 24.
The judge concluded that there was “no persuasive evidence” that Greene had taken direct actions to help the insurrectionists – such as “physical efforts, contribution of personal services or capital, issuance of directives or marching orders, transmissions of intelligence, or even statements of encouragement.” Her militant rhetoric about the election wasn’t enough to link her to the attack.
“Her public statements and heated rhetoric may well have contributed to the environment that ultimately led to the Invasion,” Beaudrot concluded. “But expressing constitutionally-protected political views, no matter how aberrant they may be, prior to being sworn in as a Representative is not engaging in insurrection under the 14th Amendment” and therefore isn’t disqualifying.
07:04 – Source: CNN
Acosta breaks down ‘the problem’ for Marjorie Taylor Greene after testimony
This outcome is yet another setback in the liberal-backed efforts to hold Republican officials responsible for the Capitol riot. It also raises fresh questions about whether similar constitutional challenges will stand a chance against former President Donald Trump if he runs again in 2024.
“This decision betrays the fundamental purpose of the Fourteenth Amendment’s Insurrectionist Disqualification Clause and gives a pass to political violence as a tool for disrupting and overturning free and fair elections,” Free Speech For People, a constitutional advocacy group that backed the challenge, said in a statement, and urged Raffensperger to disqualify Greene.
In an interview after the ruling was handed down, Greene’s lawyer, James Bopp Jr., told CNN that “this is a great day for the First Amendment and a great day for our democracy.”
“There’s a bevy of well-funded Democrat lawyers behind this political smear … they are trying to win elections by disqualifying members of Congress,” Bopp said.
Beaudrot’s recommendation comes weeks after he presided over an unprecedented all-day disqualification hearing in Atlanta, where lawyers for the voters who challenged Greene’s candidacy tried to connect her and her militant rhetoric to the violent attack on the Capitol.
She testified for more than three hours at the hearing, becoming the first member of Congress to answer questions under oath about January 6. She denied knowing about plans for violence and repeatedly said she couldn’t remember key facts – like what she discussed with White House officials about the transfer of power, and with whom she spoke as January 6 approached.
One piece of evidence that stood out to the judge was an interview Greene gave to Newsmax the day before the attack, where she was asked what the plan was for the joint session of Congress where Biden’s victory would be certified. She said, “This is our 1776 moment,” and the challengers claimed it was a coded message intended to spur Trump supporters to violence.
Beaudrot, the judge, wrote that this was “the only conduct” by Greene that came close to triggering her disqualification, but “it is impossible for the Court to conclude from this vague, ambiguous statement that Rep. Greene was complicit in a months-long enterprise to obstruct the peaceful transfer of presidential power without making an enormous unsubstantiated leap.”
Bopp, Greene’s lawyer, said Friday that the challengers’ views about the 1776 comments were a “ridiculous distortion of a simple statement” and praised the judge’s conclusion on the matter.
The judge acknowledged in his ruling that Greene had contacts with people who may have instigated violence – and she was questioned about these contacts under oath. But the judge ruled that “the evidence does not show that Rep. Greene was in contact with, directed, or assisted these individuals, or indeed anyone, in the planning or execution of the Invasion.”
Some of Greene’s testimony was undermined by recent revelations about Trump’s final chief of staff, Mark Meadows. Greene testified that she couldn’t recall if she advocated for Trump to impose martial law, but texts obtained by CNN show that Greene told Meadows on January 17, 2021, that he should raise the issue with Trump, even if she wasn’t sure if martial law was a good idea.
Similar constitutional challenges have fallen short, or are bogged down in the courts, against Republicans holding state and federal offices in North Carolina, Pennsylvania and Arizona.
This story has been updated with additional reaction and details.
Source: https://www.cnn.com/2022/05/06/politics/marjorie-taylor-greene-ballot/index.html
